Device for interacting with experts when determining cardinal coordinated estimation

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: device has input registers, NOT elements, comparison blocks, counters, indication blocks, delay elements, adders, division blocks, Or elements, commutators, subtraction blocks.

EFFECT: broader functional capabilities, higher efficiency.

8 dwg

 

The invention relates to automatic control and computer engineering and can be used to generate consistent absolute cardinal group of expert evaluation.

A device for decision-making in expert systems, containing blocks of the input estimates of the parameters of the object, the input sections of competence assessment expert, referencing the expert, the units of comparison registers grades, register the number of estimated parameters, the register number of experts, blocks the formation of estimates, the control unit, the display unit and switches (USSR author's certificate No. 1770961, CL G 06 F 15/00, 1990).

The disadvantage of this device is the lack of quantitative indication of the degree of consistency of the experts.

The closest analogue (prototype) is a device for selecting rational variant containing three groups of input registers, two groups of blocks of the comparison, the input register, the group elements And the counter element is NOT, two delay elements (EZ), the six elements, OR the four switches, six registers, the EZE group, a group of adders, two blocks comparison, a display unit, a generator of clock pulses and the pulse distributor (RF patent No. 2202822, CL G 06 F 7/06, 15/00, 2003).

A disadvantage of this device is the lack of accounting threshold level of compliance set the Expo is the shaft estimates (IER), that does not allow adjustment of expert estimates.

The technical result of the claimed invention is to improve the consistency of many individual expert assessments and accuracy radical group of expert evaluation.

This can be done as follows. Is determined by the relative competence of experts (JCMS)jaccording to the formula:

where νjnormalized absolute weight of the j-th expert;

m - number of experts.

Next are the individual expert assessments. Moreover, if valued any value, then the evaluation will be in the form of real numbers βj. When evaluated any event, the assessment will be in the form of Boolean variables αji.e. in the case of “Yes” is “unit”, as in the case of “no” will be zero.

After this estimated spectrum S, (i=1,... ,n) expert judgement by comparing the values βjwith fixed values of the scale (n is the number of divisions of the scale). Values βjby rounding belong to any division of the scale spectrum. Then summed performance evaluations βjfixed bars.

Calculate the coefficient of congruence (CC) Kn(S) the spectrum of expert assessments on four the ule:

where

n is the number of divisions of the scale spectrum expert evaluations;

m - number of experts;

Si- the number of experts whose scores are rounded up to i-th division of the scale;

cjkthe relative competence of the j-th expert.

In further determined the adequacy of the degree of coherence of expert estimations by comparing the values of KS calculated by the formula (2), with values of the detection threshold (AT) Taboutand threshold applications (PP) Tpand if

you will see the recommendation to change his testimony to the expert, which has the least JCMS.

If the value of the individual assessment has not changed, it is excluded from the IER, and the expert is removed from the team. If this value is changed, then calculate the new value of the COP by the formula (2), which again is compared with Tabout. When at a certain step has proved that inequality (3) still holds, and the number of experts that you can offer to change their estimates were empty, the process stops and a team of experts to replace.

If the inequality

then determine the average rating IER β according to the formula:

/img>

Next, calculate the criterion Fjaccording to the formula:

From m values of this criterion selects the largest value, and the corresponding expert is prompted to change his assessment. In case of failure of the expert this estimate excluded from IER. If the expert gives a new estimate, the IER is adjusted, calculates the new value of the COP by the formula (2).

After this check the following inequalities (3) and (4)in Addition, check the inequality

where ml- the number of estimated remaining IER after execution. l-step of the procedure.

This process continues until, until you are the inequality (7). If at a certain step will be the inequality

the IER is considered significant, and the average rating defined for him, I agreed aggregated expert assessment (determined by the importance of each expert in the formation of a group of expert evaluation).

If inequality (7) and (8) are not met, then calculate the average expert evaluation by the formula (5). The user can give information about the average valuation, but also on the values of KS and PCP. If these values are satisfied with it, then the process ends. Otherwise, a team of experts replace new. New experts is invited to give their individual assessment. Then all the above procedures are repeated in accordance with the specified order.

The technical result is achieved in that the device for interaction with experts when determining dramatically coherent assessment, containing from the first to the fifth input registers, the first element is NOT, first and second blocks of the comparison, the first counter, the first display unit, the first and second delay components (EZ), register, clock generator pulses, the first, second and third group of input registers, a sixth group of EZE and the first group of adders, and the output of each element of the sixth group of EZE, consisting of (m-2) elements, connected to the first input of the corresponding adder of the first group of adders consisting of (m-1) elements, starting from the second, the second input of each of which is connected to the output of the preceding adder, the output of the second unit of comparison is connected to the input of the first element is NOT, the information inputs of the first and second groups of input registers, each of which consists of m elements are the input device, information input of the third group of input registers, consisting of n elements are the input device further comprises a fourth group of input registers, from first to fifth and seventh through the tenth EZE group, the second group of adders, first and second groups elements OR the first and the which group of switches, the second and third elements are NOT, with the first seven elements OR the unit, the first and second groups of blocks dividing the first and second groups of display units, the group of registers, from the third to the sixth blocks comparison, second, third and fourth display units, from the third to the sixth EZ, second and third counters, first to fourth adders stacked, with the first through third blocks multiplication, from first to third blocks subtraction, item, group of blocks subtraction module, the first and second switches, the group of multiplier units, the unit taking the logarithm and pulse distributor, the input connected to the output of the clock generator pulses, the first, second, third and fourth outputs of the pulse distributor - with inputs recording respectively the first, second, third and fourth groups of input registers, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth outputs - inputs account respectively the first, second, third, fourth and fifth input registers, the tenth output to the inputs of the reading of the first group of input registers, the eleventh output - inputs account registers, twelfth and thirteenth outputs from the first inputs, respectively, the first and second groups of elements OR, fourteenth exit - entry reading of the second counter, the fifteenth exit - entrance read the third group of input registers,sixteenth and seventeenth outputs - with inputs respectively start and read the third counter, the eighteenth and nineteenth outputs with inputs respectively start and read the first counter, the twentieth output to the inputs of the reading of the fourth group of input registers, twenty-first and twenty-second outputs respectively from the first and second control inputs of the first switch, the twenty-third, twenty-fourth, twenty-fifth and twenty-sixth outputs - inputs are read, respectively, the fourth, first, second and third input registers, the twenty-seventh output to the input of register entries, the outputs of the first and second input registers of the first group of input registers connected respectively to the first and second inputs of the first adder of the first group of adders, and all subsequent registers of the first group of input registers their outputs connected to the inputs EZ sixth group of EZE, in addition, the output of each register of the first group of input registers connected to the inputs of each of the m elements of the fifth group of EZE, the output of each of EZE which is connected to the input of the dividend of each of the m elements of the first group of blocks dividing the output of the last adder of the first group of adders connected to the inputs of the divider of each of m elements of the first group of blocks dividing the outputs of which are connected to the input of each of m elements of the first is the group display units, as well as to the information input of each of m elements of the group of registers, input read each register group registers connected to the output of each of the m elements of the second group of elements OR, as the output - information input of each of m elements of the second group of switches, the first output of each element of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the second group of EZE, and the second output to the first input of each of m elements of the group of multiplier units, the output of each of the m elements of the second group EZ connected to the appropriate input, with the first through m-th, fifth element OR the output which is connected to the input of the account of the second counter and to the input of the third EZE, the output of which is connected to the information input of the second switch, the output of which is connected to the information input of the fourth adder stacked, the output of which is connected to the inputs of the first, fourth and sixth EZ, and also to the input of the block taking the logarithm, the output of which is connected to the first input of the third block multiplication, the second input is connected to the output of the sixth EZ, and the return to the information input of the third adder with the accumulation and to the first input of the seventh element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the account of the third counter, the output of which is connected to the first input of the fifth block of comparison, the output of which is connected with the information is the course of the first switch, first, second and third outputs of which are connected to the control inputs respectively of the first, second and third adders stacked, the last of which is connected to the input of the second EZE, the output of which is connected to the input of wichitaeagle first subtraction unit, reducing input of which is connected to the output of the second adder with the accumulation and the output to the input of the fissionable unit, the output of which is connected to the input of wichitaeagle third subtraction unit, the output of which is connected to the input of the second display unit and to the first inputs of the first and second block of comparison, the yield of the latter of which is connected to the input of the first display unit, to the first input element And to the second input of each of m elements of the second group of items OR, to the control input of each of m elements of the second group of switches to the second input of each of m elements of the first group of items OR, to the control input of each of m elements of the first group of switches, the first output of each of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the first group of EZE, and the second output to the input of each of m elements of the third group of EZE, with the second input of each of m elements of the group of multiplier units, the outputs of the first two of which are connected respectively to the first and second inputs of the first adder of the second group of adders, comp is the present of the (m-1) elements, and the output of each subsequent block multiplication from the third to the m-th to the input of the corresponding element of the seventh EZE group consisting of (m-2) elements, each element of which is connected to the first input of the corresponding adder of the second group of adders, starting from the second, the second input of each of which is connected to the output of the preceding adder, and the output of the last (m-1)-th adder is connected to the fifth input of the unit display and information input register, the output of which is connected to the input of reducing each of the m elements of the group of blocks subtraction module, the input wichitaeagle each of which is connected to the output of each of the m elements of the third group of EZE and the output to the input of the dividend of each of the m elements of the second group of blocks dividing the output of each of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the second group of display units, and the input of the divider to the output of each of the m elements of the fourth group of EZE, the input of each of which is connected with the second output of each of the m elements of the second group of switches, the output of each of the m elements of the second group of input registers connected to the information input of each of m elements of the first group of switches and the input read - the output of each of the m elements of the first group of elements OR, the output of each of the n elements of the third group of input registers connected svgdom each of the n elements of the eighth group of EZE, the output of each of which is connected to the appropriate input, from the first to the n-th, the first element OR the output of which is connected to a second input of the sixth block of comparison, the output of which is connected to the control inputs of the second switch and the fourth adder stacked, the input read register connected to the output of the fifth EZ, whose input is connected to the output element And a second input connected to the output of the third element, the input of which is connected to the output of the first unit of comparison that the same output is connected to the first input of the sixth element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the fourth display unit information inputs of the fourth group of input registers, consisting of n elements, are input devices, and output each element of this group is connected to the input of each of n elements of the ninth group of EZE and with the input of each of n elements of the tenth group of EZE, the output of each of which is connected to the appropriate input, from the first to the n-th, the second element OR the output of which is connected to the first input of the first block multiplication, the second input is connected to the output of the first EZ, and the output to the second input of the seventh element OR to the information input of the first adder with the accumulation whose output is connected to the input wichitaeagle second subtraction unit, the output of which is connected to p the pout the input of the second block multiplication, a second input connected to the output of the fourth EZ, and the output - information input of the second adder with the accumulation and with the third input of the seventh element OR the output of each of the m elements of the first group EZ connected to the appropriate input, with the first through m-th, the third element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the account of the first counter, the output of which is connected to the input of the fourth unit of comparison, the output of which is connected to a second input of the sixth element or with the input of the second element, the output of which is connected to the input of the start of the second counter, the output of which is connected to the first input the sixth block of comparison, the third input of the sixth element OR is connected to the output element And the output of each of the n elements of the ninth group EZ connected with the respective input, from the first to the n-th, the fourth element OR the output of which is connected to the inlet of the reducing of the second subtraction unit, the information inputs of the first and second input registers are input devices, and their outputs are connected with the second inputs respectively of the first and second units of comparison, the information input of the third input register is an input device, and its output connected to the second input of the fifth block of comparison, the information input to the fourth input register is input device, and its output connected to the input of the elites block division, information input to the fifth input of the register is the input device, and its output connected to the input of the third block of comparison, the output of which is connected to the input of the third display unit.

In figure 1, 2, 3 and 4 shows a functional diagram of the device for interaction with experts when determining dramatically coherent assessment (to eliminate the bulkiness of communication between the pulse distributor and the control inputs of the respective blocks are not shown in full, as indicated by the numbering of the inputs and outputs); figure 5 shows a sequence diagram of the operation of the claimed device (y-axis the numbers of outputs of the pulse distributor, and the abscissa axis is the number of cycles and duration of the various computational operations in the upper part of figure 5 (for execution timeline assumed: m=7, n=5); Fig.6 presents the General case the spectrum expert assessments; figure 7 shows a case of the greatest coherence IER; Fig case presents the lowest degree of coherence of international economic relations.

Device for interaction with experts when determining dramatically coherent assessment (1, 2, 3 and 4) contains the first 1 and second 2 groups of input registers, each of which consists of m elements, the third 3 and fourth 4 groups of input registers, each of which consists of n element is in, the first 5 second 6, third 7, 8 fourth and fifth 9 EZE group, each of which consists of m elements, 10 sixth and seventh 11 EZE group, each of which consists of (m-2) elements, eighth 12, 13 ninth and tenth 14 EZE group, each of which consists of n elements, the first 15 and second 16 groups of adders, each of which consists of (m-1) elements, the first 17 and second 18 groups of elements OR, each of which consists of m elements the first 19 and second 20 groups of switches, each of which consists of m elements, the first 21, second 22 and third 23 items are NOT, the first 24 and second 25, 26 third, fourth, 27 and 28 fifth input registers, the first 29 and second 30, 31 third, fourth, 32, 33 fifth, sixth, 34 and 35 seventh elements OR block 36 division, the first 37 and second 38 groups of blocks dividing, each of which consists of m elements, the first 39 and second 40 group display units, group 41 registers, which consists of m elements, the first 42 and second 43, 44 third, fourth, 45, 46 fifth and sixth 47 units of comparison, the first 48, 49 second, third 50, 51 fourth and fifth 52 display units, the first 53 and second 54, 55 third, fourth, 56, 57 fifth and sixth 58 EZ, the first 59 and second 60 and 61 third counters, the first 62, 63 second, third 64 and fourth adders 65 stacked, the first 66 and second 67 and 68 third blocks multiplication, the first 69, 70 second and third 71 blocks subtraction, the And gate 72, a group of 73 blocks in the subtraction modulo, which consists of m elements, the first 74 and 75 second switches, a group of 76 blocks the multiplication, which consists of m elements, the register 77, block 78 taking the logarithm, the generator 79 clock pulses and the dispenser 80 pulses.

Device for interaction with experts in the definition of the cardinal agreed evaluation works as follows. For informational inputs of each of the elements of the first group 1 input registers (1, 2, 3 and 4) zasilacze size ν1that ν2, ... , νmcharacterizing weight experts. When this control signal to the inputs of the recording of this group is supplied from the first output of the distributor 80 pulses, the rate of which is specified by the generator 79 clock pulses. For informational inputs of each of the elements of the second group 2 of the input register values are sent to the expert assessments of some event in the form of Boolean variables α1that α2, ... , αm. The control signal at the inputs of the recording of this group is fed from the second output of the distributor 80 pulses. For informational inputs of each of the elements of the third group 3 input registers send pre-defined values of S1, S2, ... , Sncharacterizing the range of expert estimates. The control signal at the inputs of the recording of this group being introduced from the third output distribution the amplifier 80 pulses. For informational inputs of each of the elements of the fourth group 4 input the inputs of each of the elements of the fourth group 4 input registers are sent values are integers real numbers from 1 to n. The control signal at the inputs of the recording of this group served with the fourth output of the distributor 80 pulses. For informational inputs of the first 24, second 25, 26 third, fourth, 27 and 28 fifth input registers are sent respectively the values of TaboutTp, n, L, and ml. The control signals on the recording inputs of these registers are given correspondingly to the fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth outputs of the distributor 80 pulses.

The signal output from the tenth dispenser 80 pulses at the inputs of the reading of the first group 1 input registers values νjare fed to the inputs of the sixth group of 10 EZ, to the inputs of the first adder of the first group 15 adders (ν1and ν2), and also to the inputs of the fifth group of 9 EZ. The presence of groups of 10, 15 and 9 provides simultaneous admission to the inputs of the dividend and the divisor of each unit of the first group of blocks 37 division values νjand. Therefore, with a group of 37 values JCMS Cjdefined by the formula (1)are directed to the inputs of the first group 39 display (for visual reference) and on the information in the odes group 41 registers. The control signal at the inputs of record group 41 is fed from the eleventh output of the distributor 80 pulses.

The signal from the twelfth output of the distributor 80 pulses at the inputs of the reading group 41 registers the values of Cjsend information to the inputs of the second group 20 switches. Moreover, the control signal from the distributor 80 pulses being introduced to the group 41 through the second group 18 elements OR. This is because the control signal to the group of registers 41 can come from the output of the second block 43 comparison. The switches 20 are configured so that, in the absence of the control signal transmitted value will come from the first outputs of the switches. Consequently, the value Ofjthis will be submitted through the second group of 6 EZ and the fifth element OR 33 alternately to the input of the account of the second counter 60 and to the input of the third EZ 55.

The signal from the thirteenth output of the distributor 80 pulses at the inputs of the reading of the second group 2 input registers values αjserved on informational inputs of the first group of 19 switches. It should be emphasized that the control signal from the distributor 80 pulses sent to group 2 through the first group of 17 elements OR. This is because the control signal for the second group 2 input registers can come from the output of the second is Loka 43 comparison. The switches 20 are configured so that, in the absence of the control signal transmitted value will come from the first outputs of the switches. Hence, values αithis will be submitted through the first group of 5 EZ and the third element OR 31 alternately to the input of the account of the first counter 59.

Due to the presence of the control signal output from the eighteenth dispenser 80 pulses to the input of the first counter 59, the counter starts counting the number of units in the aggregate of the values αj. After the end of counting on the signal from the nineteenth output of the distributor 80 pulses to the input of the reading of the first counter 59 with its release, the number of units (positive assessments of the experts) is input to the fourth unit of comparison. Only one entry in this block is due to the fact that the input value is compared with a constant number equal to one. In addition, the fourth block 45 comparison is configured as follows: if the compared value is greater than or equal to one, the output unit 45 of the signal will not be, otherwise (input zero) - the output will be the signal. Therefore, if additional expert assessments will be no positive evaluation (no units), the fourth unit 51 of the display through the sixth element 34 receives a signal and at block 51 the label inscription: “replacement required information.

When will be at least one positive output of the fourth unit 45 comparison signal, and the output of the second element 22, a signal will appear. This control signal will be supplied to the input of the start of the second counter 60, which will start to work. Estimated value of the quantity Withjthe control signal to the input of the reading of the second counter 60 with the fourteenth output of the distributor 80 pulses is fed to the first input of the sixth block 47 comparison. To another input of the block 47 by a signal from the fifteenth output of the distributor 80 pulses at the inputs of the reading of the third group 3 input registers are sequentially through eighth group of 12 EZ and the first element OR 29 to enter the values of Si. The sixth block 47 comparison is configured as follows: if the number of incoming values of CjSi, its output signal will not be, otherwise the output of block 47, a signal will appear, which will be supplied to control inputs of the second switch 75 and the fourth adder 65 with the accumulation. Only one output at the switch 75 is explained by the fact that the second output is not necessary. This switch is configured as follows: if the control signal is absent, then it ignores the value of Cjwith an output of the third EZ 55 on the information input Chet is artego adder 65 with the accumulation. This is a method of calculating the value of the σito evaluate the COP according to formula (2).

The calculated values σiare fed to the inputs of block 78 taking the logarithm, the first 53, 56 fourth and sixth 58 EZ. The control signal from the twentieth outlet valve 80 pulses to the input of the reading of the fourth group 4 input registers size i arrive at the inputs 13 ninth and tenth 14 groups EZE. Outputs of group 14 of the values i through the second element OR 30 sequentially fed to the input of the first block 66 multiplication, the other input of which is supplied with the output of the first EZ 53 is σi. From the output of block 66 value i· σisend information to the input of the first adder 62 stacked, as well as through the seventh element OR 35 at the counting input of the third counter 61, which begins to work with the aid of a control signal at its input starting from the sixteenth output of the distributor 80 pulses.

After receipt of the n values of i· σithe inputs of the blocks 62 and 61 of the control signal output from the seventeenth dispenser 80 pulses to the input of the third reading of the counter 61, the number of terms i· σiis input to the fifth block 46 comparison. To another input of the block 46 is routed to a signal from the twenty-sixth output of the distributor 80 pulses to the input of the third reading is about the input register 26 to the desired number of terms n. The fifth block 46 comparison is configured as follows: if the number of summands is equal to the value n, then its output will appear on the control signal, which is supplied to the information input of the first switch 74. This switch is configured so that, in the absence of control actions control signal will appear at the output, which is connected to the input of the reading out of the first adder 62 stacked. In the presence of control actions from the twenty-first and twenty-second outputs of the distributor 80 pulses of the control signal from outputs of the first switch 74 will be transmitted to the inputs read other adders stacked.

Thus, at the output of the first adder 62 with the accumulation will have a value of. Similarly implemented, the calculation of the other components of the numerator of the formula (2). The value of the numerator of the formula (2) with the output of the first block 69 subtraction is input to the dividend unit 36 division, to the input of the divider which is directed from the output of the fourth input register 27 the value of L at a signal from the twenty-third outlet valve 80 pulses to the input read register 27. Quotient of these quantities being introduced to the input of the third block 71 subtraction. The absence of a second entrance to the block 71 is explained by the fact that reducing figurer is no constant - unit. Therefore, from the output of the block 71 is the COP calculated by the formula (2), is input to the second unit 49 displays, as well as to the inputs of the first 42 and second 43 units of comparison.

The degree of consistency of expert estimates graphically illustrated in Fig.6, 7 and 8. Figure 6 shows a General case. Here for the fourth division of the scale (i=4) Si(S4)=2. To have a value equal to four, gave two experts. Figure 7 presents the case the greatest degree of coherence of international economic relations, that is, all experts have the same opinion. On Fig shows a case of the smallest degree of coherence of international economic relations, that is, all the experts have different opinions.

On the other inputs of the first 42 and second 43 units of comparison are received respectively the values of Taboutand Tpthe signals from the twenty-fourth and twenty-fifth outputs of the distributor 80 pulses at the inputs of the reading out of the first 24 and second 25 registers. The first comparison unit 42 is configured as follows: if Kn(S)<Tothen the output of this block is the signal, otherwise the signal will not. The second block 43 comparison is configured as follows: if Kn(S)<Tnthen the output of this block is the signal, otherwise the signal will not.

This attitude of these blocks makes use of the fourth block 51 of the display to see the text: “not what bhadka replacement information” (low KS). In addition, a signal is applied to the first block 48 of the display to see the text “agreed valuation” (high COP).

At the time of obtaining the values of KS for informational inputs of each of the elements of the second group 2 of the input register values are sent to the expert assessments of some quantity in the form of real numbers β1that β2, ... , βmThe control signal at the inputs of the recording of this group is fed from the second output of the distributor 80 pulses. Reading values βjusing the control signal from the second unit 43 comparison flowing through the first group of elements OR 17. Since the control inputs of the first group of switches 19, a signal will appear, the noise value will appear on her second outputs. Therefore, values βjwill be routed to the inputs of the third group of EZE and inputs group 76 multiplier units. On the other inputs group 76 on the control signal of the second unit 43 comparison with the group of registers 41 through the second group of 20 switches zasilacze value of Cj.

Output group 76 blocks the multiplication value βjCjgo to the seventh group of EZE 11 and the second group of 16 adders, which provide the calculation of β by the formula (5). The average assessment IER β is input to the fifth b the eye zone, as well as information on the input of the register 77. Control signal to the input of the entries in this register is sent from the twenty-seventh output of the distributor 80 pulses.

In the future by calculating the criterion Fjin accordance with the formula (6). The control signal from the fifth EZ 57 to the input read register 77 with its output value β directed to the inputs of the reducing group 73 blocks subtraction modulo. The inputs wichitaeagle with the outputs of the third group of EZE 7 serving size βj. Output group 73 values |β -βj| send to the inputs of the dividend of the second group 38 units of the division, to the inputs of the divider which is sent from the outputs of the fourth group of EZE 8 value of Cj. Consequently, the outputs of the band 38 to the inputs of the second group 40 display units will be submitted value of the criterion Fjon the basis of which is selected expert, which proposed to amend its assessment.

In the absence of control on the output of the second block 43 comparison is the following inequality (7). Due to the presence of the first element 21 to the input of the reading of the fifth input of the register 28, the value of mlwill be sent to the input of the third block 44 comparison. The lack of a second input of this block is connected with the fact that the comparison of the values of mlis post the regular number - three. The block 44 is configured as follows: if ml>3, the signal at the output will not be, otherwise the signal will take place. Thus, if the number of estimates of remaining in IER after performing the l-step of the procedure will be less than three, then the output of block 44 to the input of the third block 50 zone will receive the signal, it appears the inscription: “a message to the user”. If the user is satisfied with the information about the average rating of β and on the values of CS and PP, then the process ends. Otherwise brigade replace new and the calculations are repeated. Partial replacement brigade is also possible with the display label “replacement required information.

Industrial applicability of the invention is that it can be used in different areas (sectors) in the handling and use of expert judgement, for example, in the process of independent forensic examination of environmental problems.

A device for calculation of the coefficient of consistency and determine the degree of consistency of expert evaluations, containing from the first to the fifth input registers, the first element is NOT, first and second blocks of the comparison, the first counter, the first display unit, the first and second delay components (EZ), register, clock generator pulses, the first, second and third input region is TRS, sixth group of EZE and the first group of adders, and the output of each element of the sixth group of EZE, consisting of (m-2) elements, connected to the first input of the corresponding adder of the first group of adders consisting of (m-1) elements, starting from the second, the second input of each of which is connected to the output of the preceding adder, the output of the second unit of comparison is connected to the input of the first element is NOT, the information inputs of the first and second groups of input registers, each of which consists of m elements are the input device, information input of the third group of input registers, consisting of n elements are the input devices, characterized in that it further comprises a fourth group of input registers, from first to fifth and seventh through the tenth EZE group, the second group of adders, first and second groups of elements OR the first and second groups of switches, the second and third elements are NOT, with the first seven elements OR the unit, the first and second groups of blocks dividing the first and second groups of display units, the group of registers, from the third to the sixth blocks comparison, second, third and fourth display units, from the third to the sixth EZ the second and third counters, first to fourth adders stacked, with the first through third blocks multiplication, from first to third blocks subtraction element And the group block is in deduction modulo, the first and second switches, the group of multiplier units, the unit taking the logarithm and pulse distributor, the input connected to the output of the clock generator pulses, the first, second, third and fourth outputs of the pulse distributor - with inputs recording respectively the first, second, third and fourth groups of input registers, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth outputs - inputs account respectively the first, second, third, fourth and fifth input registers, the tenth output to the inputs of the reading of the first group of input registers, the eleventh output - inputs account registers, twelfth and thirteenth the outputs from the first inputs, respectively, the first and second groups of elements OR fourteenth exit - entry reading of the second counter, the fifteenth exit - entrance read the third group of input registers, sixteenth and seventeenth outputs with inputs respectively start and read the third counter, the eighteenth and nineteenth outputs with inputs respectively start and read the first counter, the twentieth output to the inputs of the reading of the fourth group of input registers, twenty-first and twenty-second outputs respectively from the first and second control inputs of the first switch, the twenty-third, twenty-fourth, twenty-fifth and twenty-Christ.estay outputs - inputs are read, respectively, the fourth, first, second and third input registers, the twenty-seventh output to the input of register entries, the outputs of the first and second input registers of the first group of input registers connected respectively to first and second inputs of the first adder of the first group of adders, and all subsequent registers of the first group of input registers their outputs connected to the inputs EZ sixth group of EZE, in addition, the output of each register of the first group of input registers connected to the inputs of each of the m elements of the fifth group of EZE, the output of each of EZE which is connected to the input of the dividend of each of the m elements of the first group of blocks dividing the output of the last adder of the first group of adders connected to the inputs of the divider of each of the m elements of the first group of blocks dividing the outputs of which are connected to the input of each of m elements of the first group of display units, as well as to the information input of each of m elements of the group of registers, input read each register group registers connected to the output of each of the m elements of the second group of elements OR, as the output - information input of each of m elements of the second group of switches, the first output of each element of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the second group of EZE, and the second output to the first input of each of m elements group blocks the multiplication, the output of each the m elements of the second group EZ connected to the appropriate input, first to m-th, fifth element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the account of the second counter and to the input of the third EZE, the output of which is connected to the information input of the second switch, the output of which is connected to the information input of the fourth adder stacked, the output of which is connected to the inputs of the first, fourth and sixth EZ, and also to the input of the block taking the logarithm, the output of which is connected to the first input of the third block multiplication, the second input is connected to the output of the sixth EZ, and the return to the information input of the third adder with the accumulation and to the first input of the seventh element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the account of the third counter, the output of which is connected to the first input of the fifth block of comparison, the output of which is connected to the information input of the first switch, the first, second and third outputs of which are connected to the control inputs respectively of the first, second and third adders stacked, the last of which is connected to the input of the second EZE, the output of which is connected to the input of wichitaeagle first subtraction unit, reducing input of which is connected to the output of the second adder with the accumulation and the output to the input of the fissionable unit, the output of which is connected to the input of wichitaeagle third subtraction unit, the output which is connected to the input of the second block is and display and to the first inputs of the first and second Comparer, the yield of the latter of which is connected to the input of the first display unit, to the first input element And to the second input of each of m elements of the second group of items OR, to the control input of each of m elements of the second group of switches to the second input of each of m elements of the first group of items OR, to the control input of each of m elements of the first group of switches, the first output of each of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the first group of EZE, and the second output to the input of each of m elements of the third group of EZE, with the second input of each of m elements group multiplier units, the outputs of the first two of which are connected respectively to first and second inputs of the first adder of the second group of adders consisting of (m-1) elements, and the output of each subsequent block multiplication from the third to the m-th to the input of the corresponding element of the seventh EZE group consisting of (m-2) elements, each element of which is connected to the first input of the corresponding adder of the second group of adders, starting from the second, the second input of each of which is connected to the output of the preceding adder, and the output of the last (m-1)-th adder is connected to the fifth input of the unit display and information input register, the output of which is connected to the input of reducing each of the m elements of the group of blocks viitaniemi module, entrance wichitaeagle each of which is connected to the output of each of the m elements of the third group of EZE and the output to the input of the dividend of each of the m elements of the second group of blocks dividing the output of each of which is connected to the input of each of m elements of the second group of display units, and the input of the divider to the output of each of the m elements of the fourth group of EZE, the input of each of which is connected with the second output of each of the m elements of the second group of switches, the output of each of the m elements of the second group of input registers connected to the information input of each of m elements of the first group of switches, and the entrance read to the output of each of the m elements of the first group of elements OR, the output of each of the n elements of the third group of input registers connected to the input of each of n elements of the eighth group of EZE, the output of each of which is connected to the appropriate input, from the first to the n-th, the first element OR the output of which is connected to a second input of the sixth block of comparison, the output of which is connected to the control inputs of the second switch and the fourth adder stacked, the input read register connected to the output of the fifth EZ, whose input is connected to the output element And a second input connected to the output the third element, the input of which is connected to the output of the first unit of comparison that the same output with the Dinan to the first input of the sixth element, OR the output of which is connected to the fourth input of the display unit, the information input of the fourth group of input registers, consisting of n elements, are input devices, and output each element of this group is connected to the input of each of n elements of the ninth group of EZE and with the input of each of n elements of the tenth group of EZE, the output of each of which is connected to the appropriate input, from the first to the n-th, the second element OR the output of which is connected to the first input of the first block multiplication, the second input is connected to the output of the first EZ, and the output to the second input of the seventh element OR and to the information input of the first adder with the accumulation, the output of which is connected to the input wichitaeagle second subtraction unit, the output of which is connected to the first input of the second block multiplication, a second input connected to the output of the fourth EZ, and the output - information input of the second adder with the accumulation and with the third input of the seventh element OR the output of each of the m elements of the first group EZ connected to the appropriate input, with the first through m-th, the third element OR the output of which is connected to the input of the account of the first counter, the output of which is connected to the input of the fourth unit of comparison, the output of which connected with the second input of the sixth element or with the input of the second element, the output of which is connected to the input of the start of the second counter, the output of which is connected to the first input of the sixth block of comparison, the third input of the sixth element OR is connected to the output element And the output of each of the n elements of the ninth group EZ connected with the respective input, from the first to the n-th, the fourth element OR the output of which is connected to the inlet of the reducing of the second subtraction unit, the information inputs of the first and second input registers are input devices, and their outputs are connected with the second inputs respectively of the first and second units of comparison, the information input of the third input register is an input device, and its output connected to the second input of the fifth block of comparison, information input to the fourth input register is an input device, and its output connected to the input of the divider block division information input to the fifth input of the register is the input device, and its output connected to the input of the third block of comparison, the output of which is connected to the input of the third display unit.



 

Same patents:

FIELD: computers, finance.

SUBSTANCE: system has authentication block for participants of tender, block for selection of base address of records of tender participants, block for modifying base address of record, block for commutation of channels, first and second comparators, first and second counters, four registers, AND elements, OR elements and delay elements.

EFFECT: higher speed of operation.

13 dwg

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: variants of methods include forming of blocks for controlling terminals, which generally match transactions, performed by automated transaction machine. Terminal control blocks control visually formed links between multiple objects of automated transaction machine in workspace. As objects following objects are used: authorization object, concealed control object, object of device for reading from card, client profile object, depositor object, dispensing device object, auxiliary keyboard object, logical object, server object, presenter object, PIN-code input object, printer object, synchronization object and transaction data object. Devices realize operations of methods.

EFFECT: higher reliability.

17 cl, 59 dwg

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: system has block for receiving data record identifiers, device for selecting base addresses of database records, device for selecting relative addresses of database records, block for forming summary address of database record, counter, block for identification of database records, block for setting actualization mode, register and block for selecting number of records of database.

EFFECT: higher speed of operation.

8 dwg

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: system has processing and information server, connected to means of inter-network interface of communications operator and computers of at least two alternative sources of common type goods and/or services with possible receiving of information from each of noted sources. Processing and information server has data input block, block for storing data about goods and/or services and block for indexing and searching for information, and also means for access of users of communication devices to data storage block with data about goods and/or services, connected to means of inter-network interface of communications operator. Also, computers of sources of goods and/or services are made in form of external database servers and are connected to processing and information server with possible automatic transfer of information to processing and information server with its renewal at external server.

EFFECT: operative structuring of information about goods and/or services and providing of this information to users of mobile communication devices with possible navigation across catalogue and full-text search.

7 cl, 17 dwg

FIELD: documents classification systems.

SUBSTANCE: method is based on multiple use of simple classifier for classifying document and following correction of classification results with consideration of thematic dependences between categories.

EFFECT: possible a priori setting of dependences of categories from each other in form of categories tree.

3 dwg

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: device has random time ranges generators, imitating specific usage modes, elements AND, OR, triggers, delay elements, random numbers generators, decrypters and differentiative elements, providing for modeling of dynamics and specifics of operation of surface mobile measuring complex.

EFFECT: higher precision, broader functional capabilities.

2 dwg

FIELD: computer science.

SUBSTANCE: device has random time ranges generators, imitating specific usage modes, elements AND, OR, triggers, delay elements, random numbers generators, decrypters and differentiative elements, providing for modeling of dynamics and specifics of operation of surface mobile measuring complex.

EFFECT: higher precision, broader functional capabilities.

2 dwg

FIELD: the invention refers to the technique of detection of a target and determination of the direction at a target.

SUBSTANCE: the mode is realized by way of receiving of ultra wideband impulses reflected from the target, of delaying them on various time multitude in various channels of surveillance and multi channel processing. In the first variant of the current mode variation of the form of receiving impulses on a great number of discrete time positions are carried out by way of averaging-out by channels of surveillance at known direction of incoming reflected impulses in a beforehand designed control sector and then found valuation of the form of receiving impulse is used as a base signal in multi channel correlation processing. In the second variant valuation of magnitude of receiving impulse is formed in concrete moment of time for each base direction in beforehand given angular sector of control, valuation of the form of the receiving impulse is found according to formed valuations of magnitude 0f the receiving signal for various discrete moments of time; found valuation of receiving impulse is used as a base signal in multi channel correlation processing; out of multitude of results of correlation processing correlation maximum is chosen. This maximum is used as preliminary threshold decision statistics in the procedure of detection of the target; the direction of incoming reflected impulses with the help of interpolating valuation of the position of the correlation maximum in the environs of that base direction for which the largest result of multi channel correlation processing.

EFFECT: the use of this invention at location of a target with the help of ultra wideband impulses allows to receive signals incoming not only from in advance chosen base directions.

6 cl,9 dwg

FIELD: access control systems, ATMs.

SUBSTANCE: controller has control signals generator, state analyzer, signals detector, executive device, state indicator.

EFFECT: simplified construction, higher efficiency.

3 dwg

FIELD: access control technologies.

SUBSTANCE: system for controlling information concerning subscribers for use with broadcast system, providing phone services and internet services to subscriber, includes means for storing subscribers parameters, having relation to subscription of current subscriber for television services (B-parameters), and means for storing internet-parameters of subscribers, related to subscription of current subscriber for internet services, while this system for controlling information is different because said internet parameters and B-parameters are interconnected and it also has means for allowing internet access to subscriber with certain B-parameters.

EFFECT: facilitated processing of subscribers parameters.

2 cl, 6 dwg

FIELD: formation of payment documents.

SUBSTANCE: the information meaningful for the payment document is introduced in the computer of the financial settlements and check-out center, the payment document is formed in the form a text and the first dot-and-dash code line and introduced in the electronic data base, the document is displayed for payment to the payer, the payer introduces the information on the quantity of consumed resources and the sum of payments to the document according to the acting tariff rates, these data are introduced in the cash register of the payment reception center with the date of payment, types and sums of payments, these data and the second dot-and-dash code line with these data on the document are represented by means of the cash register, it is sent to the financial settlements and check-out center, the first and second dot-and-dash code lines are read out, the information is compared with the electronic base, entered together with the information on reception of the payment in its electronic data base.

EFFECT: automated formation of documents with due account made for payments determined by the floor space, quantity of people living there and the quantity of the consumed resources.

8 cl, 1 dwg

FIELD: message boards and mail servers.

SUBSTANCE: electronic message board is provided with database in form of several known words, which are selected in specific order, while each word is connected to respective URI. Message text from user computer is checked using a plurality of known words. When message text does not include a known word of plurality of known words, message is placed at electronic board. Each known word is found in text, known in text is converted to hypertext format with URI connected to word, as destination of link, and message is placed at message board.

EFFECT: higher efficiency.

7 cl, 4 dwg

FIELD: data access technologies.

SUBSTANCE: method includes assignment of simplified network address, recording URL and converting numbers into storage system with net access, inputting assigned number into computer, transferring inputted number to storage system, converting number to URL, receiving page matching URL, and displaying it. Method for use in operation systems for message transfer include intercepting system level messages to certain objects and forming pseudonym messages during that. Systems realize said methods.

EFFECT: broader functional capabilities.

12 cl, 30 dwg

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: system has entries memory block, words memory block, control block, substitutions block, n blocks for searching and replacing.

EFFECT: broader functional capabilities.

17 dwg

FIELD: measurement technology.

SUBSTANCE: method can be used for criminal and official inquires of road accidents. Method is based upon measurement of speed of pedestrian and calculation its arithmetical mean. Method differs from known ones, as speed of motion is measured experimentally 10 to 30 times with three different pedestrians having like age and physical condition as victim of run-over. Results are processed as small sample by using central deviations and those deviations are used to determine average meaning of speed of motion, standard deviation, error and truth of the average mean. Upon finding truth of average mean the necessary number of trials is calculated which number has to be compared with real number of trials. Additional trials are conducted if necessary. Factor of truth of experimental data is calculated from speeds of motion of pedestrians taking part in experiment. Probability and factor of confidence is determined accordingly to speed of motion of injured person and speeds of motion of pedestrians involved into experiment, as well as according to truth of preset limit values of this parameter. If values of preset factors correspond to legitimate values or limits admitted for investigation of road accidents, statistically true minimal and maximal values of speed of motion of injured pedestrian are calculated on the base of normal distribution law by means of subtraction the speed from its average value and addition of product of factor of confidence with standard deviation. Limit values of speed of motion of injured pedestrian are presented for forensic examination to make calculations determining availability or lack of availability of prevention of run-over. For this purpose the statistically truthful minimal and maximal values of speed of motion of injured pedestrian should be calculated in relation to accessible values or limits of probability which is higher than 0,95 and if confidence with speed of motion of injured pedestrian and pedestrians involved into experiment correspond to each other. Preset precision of pedestrian's speed of motion should be within limits of +-0,5 km/hour.

EFFECT: improved precision of measurement; higher probability of prevention of road accident.

2cl, 2 tbl

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: system has nine registers, four address selectors, triggers, AND elements, OR elements and delay elements.

EFFECT: higher speed.

8 dwg

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: system has nine registers, four address selectors, triggers, AND elements, OR elements and delay elements.

EFFECT: higher speed.

8 dwg

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: device has control trigger, random pulse generators, block for forming program of functioning of modeled multimode system, working modes and technological mode blocks, operation time counters, random pulses generators, OR block, orders counters.

EFFECT: broader functional capabilities.

3 dwg

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: device has control trigger, random pulse generators, block for forming program of functioning of modeled multimode system, working modes and technological mode blocks, operation time counters, random pulses generators, OR block, orders counters.

EFFECT: broader functional capabilities.

3 dwg

FIELD: computers.

SUBSTANCE: invention is based on representation of mother wavelet in spectral plane with following logarithmical scaling of mother wavelet.

EFFECT: simplified operation.

6 cl, 6 dwg

Up!